view photos


A Stone's Throw from the Beach with Plans for Proposed Second Floor

17 Bay Avenue, Sag Harbor, NY 11963


Enjoy Sag Harbor serenity and style in this charming, fully renovated three-bedroom, one-bathroom shingle-style home just inches from Noyack Bay beaches. Spanning 1,247 square feet, this gracious cottage is filled with airy sunlight and tranquil beachside ambiance. Deep-stained hardwood paves the floors while vaulted beamed ceilings soar overhead in the welcoming living room. The chef's kitchen is beautifully equipped with Shaker cabinetry topped in butcher block and classic subway tiles that surround new stainless steel appliances, including a gas range, dishwasher and built-in microwave. The adjacent dining area features designer lighting and spectacular outdoor views, and al fresco entertaining is irresistible in this home's sprawling backyard, boasting a spacious deck and swimming pool surrounded by a lush lawn and a canopy of tall trees. Inside, three sunny bedrooms are tucked down a quiet hallway and each features custom wall coverings and paint details. The large windowed bathroom dazzles with marble tile, wainscoting, a soaking tub and glass shower. A separate door here leads directly to a convenient outdoor shower as well. Central air and gas heat provide year round comfort while handsome shingles, landscaping and a bright yellow door add delightful curb appeal to this lovely Hamptons charmer. Located on a peaceful tree-lined street a stone's throw from shops and bay beach with Bridge Golf Club, Noyac Golf Club and Morton National Wildlife Refuge nearby. Five minutes to Sag Harbor Village.
Please email for all showings and inquiries.
For additional information, please call or text Matt Breitenbach (631) 255-6221.


3 Beds

1 Bath

1,250 Sq.Ft. Living Area

0.22 Acres Lot

Features & Amenities


Total Bedrooms 3
Total Bathrooms 1
Full Bathrooms 1
Other Interior Features Finished Basement, Beamed Ceilings, Vaulted Ceilings


Other Exterior Features Private Beach, Heated Pool

Area & Lot

Status Sold
TOTAL AREA 1,250 Sq.Ft.
LOT SIZE 0.22 Acres
MLS® ID 348164
Year Built 1998
Neighborhood Sag Harbor
lifestyles Beach


SALES PRICE $1,200,000
A Stone's Throw from the Beach with Plans for Proposed Second Floor

"One-bathroom shingle-style home just inches from Noyack Bay beaches. "

Matthew Breitenbach

Sag Harbor

The most laid-back corner of the Hamptons. Sag Harbor has earned the nickname ‘the UnHampton’ from visitors and residents who love the contrast between this hip, diverse, and artistically vibrant corner of the Hamptons and its placid neighbors.

Work With Us

Matthew has a reputation for consistently carrying one of the most impressive luxury listing platforms in the marketplace. Contact Matthew today for a free consultation for buying, selling, renting or investing in the Hamptons.