9 Amity Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Charming Cottage in Prime Village Location

The perfect sophisticated Sag Harbor Village cottage by a noted architect and designer has every modern amenity and comfort with rich historic details.
The 2000 square foot 2 bedroom, 2 bath home on a quiet street in the heart of the village is set back from a white picket fence, with a welcoming double Dutch door. A regally proportioned great room features 20’ high ceiling, expansive brick herringbone hearth, light filled living room and dining area which opens through French doors onto a private terrace and box-hedged, beautifully landscaped back yard. Custom details abound of period hardware, moldings, trim and window treatments. A ground floor master suite with marble and tile full bath also opens onto a lovely outdoor lounging area. A well-outfitted kitchen completes the first level. Up an impressive staircase is a second bedroom, full bath, and large linen closet. A lower level offers a butler’s pantry perfect for entertaining as well as a large multi-use room for an office or den and plenty of storage. This private oasis is just steps from the main street of the Victorian Village with shops, restaurants, galleries, theaters and a yacht filled harbor reminiscent of Sag Harbor’s rich whaling history.




Matthew Breitenbach

Matthew Breitenbach


The Hamptons' Leading Broker



Features & Amenities


  • bedrooms2
  • total baths2
  • full baths2
  • other interior FeaturesFamily Room, Air Conditioning, Den, Fireplace

Area & Lot

  • Living Area2000 Sq.Ft.
  • Status Sold
  • MLS ID351614
  • LifestylesBeach, Historic, New Construction


  • PRICE$3,995,000
Charming Cottage in Prime Village Location
Charming Cottage in Prime Village Location

Welcoming, warm, comfortable, extravagant, unique and richly imagined for sophisticated owners of international and u...

– Matthew Breitenbach
Charming Cottage in Prime Village Location

Sag Harbor

The most laid-back corner of the Hamptons. Sag Harbor has earned the nickname ‘the UnHampton’ from visitors and residents who love the contrast between this hip, diverse, and artistically vibrant corner of the Hamptons and its placid neighbors.


Work With Us

Matthew has a reputation for consistently carrying one of the most impressive luxury listing platforms in the marketplace. Contact Matthew today for a free consultation for buying, selling, renting or investing in the Hamptons.

Contact Us